E-Bikes in Condos: Can Your Board Ban Your Battery-Powered Ride?
Many electric micromobility devices rely on high-energy batteries. Lithium-ion batteries are generally safe when certified, undamaged and used properly. However, damaged, modified or improperly charged batteries can overheat, ignite or explode through a process known as thermal runaway.
The risks increase when residents use incompatible chargers or batteries, leave devices charging unattended or ignore the manufacturer’s instructions. “Super chargers”, designed to charge batteries more quickly, raise concerns when users leave devices plugged in after charging is complete.
Due to the popularity of electric micromobility devices, many Boards are now grappling with whether to ban or regulate them.
The CAT approves a complete ban
A recent decision of the Condominium Authority Tribunal (CAT) upheld a rule that prohibited e-bikes and other electric micromobility devices anywhere on the condominium property. The decision confirms that condominium corporations can choose to regulate these devices or ban them altogether.
The resident challenging the rule argued that it was too broad. His e-bike used a sealed lead-acid battery, not a lithium-ion battery. He had not modified it, used the original charger and had stored the bike on the property for 15 months without incident. He offered to provide technical information and make the e-bike available for inspection.
The CAT still upheld the rule.
The Board was not required to prove, through expert evidence, that a particular e-bike would cause a fire. Nor was it required to create exceptions based on battery type or have management individually evaluate devices, batteries and chargers. It was entitled to adopt a blanket prohibition, which is a clear, uniform rule addressing a reasonably perceived safety risk.
Is a ban the right approach for your community?
The basis of the CAT’s decision was a long-standing principle that the role of a court or tribunal in assessing a rule is to decide whether the rule is unreasonable, not whether a different rule might be preferable. The decision is not an endorsement of banning e-bikes.
A complete ban is not necessarily the answer for all communities. Ultimately, each Board will need to make a decision that is best for its community.
While fire safety is an important consideration, fire-resistant charging cabinets and battery lockers are entering the market. Some providers advertise separate compartments, ventilation, heat/gas detection, monitoring and automatic fire suppression. These products may provide another option for Boards to consider and discuss with their insurance professionals.
Condominiums that choose to permit electric micromobility devices should keep in mind that the Ontario government recently announced proposed changes to the Fire Code.
The government’s website notes that “many of the recently raised fire safety concerns relate to the improper use, charging, and storage of lithium-ion batteries, particularly those associated with lithium-ion battery-powered micromobility devices (e.g., e-bicycles)”.
The amendments are still in the consultation phase, but the proposal is to have regulations that would:
- prohibit the unauthorized modification of lithium-ion batteries;
- ensure the safe disposal of lithium-ion batteries; and
- prohibit charging, parking, and storing of lithium-ion battery-powered micromobility devices and their batteries in lobbies serving as an access to an exit, public corridors or exits.
Condominiums will, at a minimum, have to comply with the Fire Code requirements, but Boards may want to include additional protections such as a requirement to register with management, evidence of a recognized Canadian safety certification, and provisions as to where the batteries may be stored.
Human Rights Considerations
A condominium’s rules remain subject to the Human Rights Code. Accommodation requests should be addressed on a case-by-case basis.
Boards should not assume that only conventional mobility devices engage the Code. For example, a resident may require an e-bike because a disability prevents them from using a conventional bicycle. Even if the e-bike is not required to live in the unit, a prohibition may still adversely affect the person because of a disability and trigger the duty to accommodate. Condominium corporations responding to a request for accommodation would be well advised to seek legal advice.
This article provides general commentary and is not legal advice.